Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Paper Reading #4: Shape-Changing Mobiles: Tapering in Two-Dimensional Deformational Displays in Mobile Phones

Title:
Shape-Changing Mobiles: Tapering in Two-Dimensional Deformational Displays in Mobile Phones

Comments:
Steven Hennesy
Vince Kocks

Reference:
Hemmert, F., Hamann, S., Lowe, M., Zeipelt, J., Joost, G.  Shape-Changing Mobiles: Tapering in Two-Dimensional Deformational Displays in Mobile Phones.  CHI EA '10.  Deutsche Telekom Laboratories, Berlin, Germany. http://portal.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1753920&CFID=5889600&CFTOKEN=71833395.

Summary:

This study focused on shape changing technology in mobile phones.  The shape change was proposed for ergonomical use, displaying internal contents, and using the phone as a pointer.  The paper mostly relays the information gathered on the users in estimating the angle of the tilted back panel.

The way the experiment was set up was that a mock-phone was designed with a backplate that could tilt in four directions (on two different axis).  Users were asked to estimate the tilt of the phone for both the x-axis and y-axis.  Another smaller aspect of the experiment was that compared to this use of a phone, another phone was developed that shifted weight rather than tilted.  User feedback was recorded on all the devices.

The results showed that while users were not great at estimating the tilt, there was a correlation between the error at which they guessed wrong; they were off by similar margins.  The tilted phone was much more preferable than the weight shifting phone.  Users claimed they liked the idea of a tilted shape phone rather than "the alternative".

Discussion:

This paper had extremely relevant information about the study.  This was one of the first papers I read for this class that actually showed the users opinion of the experiment.  I really appreciated that because I am always interested in how the user felt about the study.  I was a bit disappointed that they did not ask the user how they liked the design compared to their own phone.  They may have asked that when the authors referred to "the alternative", but I am not sure.

I am all about having a slim phone, and it seems like any addition to the depth of the phone would upset me.  I think it is a good idea to increase the ergonomical nature of phones, but not at the expense of depth.

Future work that I may like to see would be different sizes of phones with this ergonomical feature.

3 comments:

  1. I read this paper too and I think what they meant by "the alternative" in the paper was the weight-shifting mobile they also designed and describe in a different paper. I agree with you that it would have been nice to see what the users thought of the device in comparison to their current cell phones. Perhaps that's what they'll look into next.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm not all that concerned with the width of my phone. If it works reliably and fits comfortably in my pocket, then it's alright with me. A phone that could tilt would be intriguing to me, but I wonder how much value it would truly add to a phone as opposed to say, a tablet computer.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I personally don't think that this is a good application. I am not sure the benefit of having a phone with a moving back cover. However, this could be used in other area for some interesting applications.

    ReplyDelete